Help mayday mayday 46f1600 vs 46r452a

[gsmart329]

Let me start by thanking this forum. I think this is the only place where i can read the review of TV sets being sold out currently in India along with their price quotes.

Before asking the question i have been through each thread on this forum. Still i Didnt get the answer i was looking for.

My budget- 70k-75k
screen size- 46inch - 50inch
Requirement- PQ, very good PQ for HD and SD. I watch news,cricket, movies frm HDD
LED ONLY
NOT INTERESTED IN INTERNET/SMART TV

shortlisted after lot of research SONY 46R452A VS Samsung 46F6100 (UA46F6100AR)

Price- sony46R452A - 73,900 INR
SAMSUNG 46F6100- 75,000 INR + BD F5100 FREE+ 2 3D glasses

Iam from Nagpur. And in big dilemma from last 1 week. Had no Plan of buying 3D tv but cost is coming up almost same. I want best PQ, nothing else. Iam more tilted toward F6100, but not a single person on this forum had reviewed this set. Nor iam able to find decent review on internet.

Any help will be appreciated. Any OWNER OF F6100 to help me ???? You can also recommend me any other model if its in my budget. (MAX 75k)

 

[sanchits]

My suggestion...if u r not interested in 3d...go for the Panasonic 50e6d. Go through the threads n u'll find plenty of threads discussing the Panasonic E6 series n plenty more members vouching for it.
Completely chuck out the Sony r45 series led out of ur list...not worth it all n it's not even made by Sony AFAIK.
The panny 42e6 cost Arnd 52k in Delhi...I am sure the 50" should be in ur budget n would be considerably larger then the 46" sammy.
Anyways, I've already said enough about the panny E6 series on this forum, let other members pitch in...I have started to sound like a spokesperson for panny... Lol !

 

[Naturelover]

Hi,
I have the Panasonic 42E6D in the bedroom. Amazing TV. Contemplating getting the 50" for the living room in a few days. Will be more than 75k in Nagpur.
Don't get distracted by the freebies of Samsung!

 

[sanchits]

Hi,
I have the Panasonic 42E6D in the bedroom. Amazing TV. Contemplating getting the 50" for the living room in a few days. Will be more than 75k in Nagpur.
Don't get distracted by the freebies of Samsung!

Man...u have become a true E6 lover...great, can't imagine how good would the 50" look n it's quite VFM too compared to others.
I actually started this whole craze about the E6 with my thread w600 vs E6...through which I finally decided to go in for a 32E6 n now contemplating the 42E6.
Since then others have already bought it n I hv still not got one...:sad:

 

[gsmart329]

where to find the best price for panasonic in nagpur ?

 

[Naturelover]

Man...u have become a true E6 lover...great, can't imagine how good would the 50" look n it's quite VFM too compared to others.
I actually started this whole craze about the E6 with my thread w600 vs E6...through which I finally decided to go in for a 32E6 n now contemplating the 42E6.
Since then others have already bought it n I hv still not got one...:sad:

I hope I am not getting too repetitive!
But then it is a wonderful piece.

 

[nikhilmk9]

I am planning for 46 inch LED panel .Got the following quotes .

Samsung 46F5100 -68k
Sony 46R452A -68k
Panasonic L47E5D -70k

In Pana Showroom i found 42ET5 which had the best pq .But then 47 of this model might not be in my budget.
I need 46/47 inch for my hall.Budget 60k-70k

So guys help me out to choose between the three models above .