Got a reply from JL on the topic.
They do not recommend high level input.
Hello,
Thank you for your support of JL Audio and the e110 powered subwoofer.
The e110 does provide both the RCA line inputs and the high level to low level speaker adapter connections for use where a true preamp signal is not available. The high level connection is not our first choice when the RCA connections are available.
Here is the section of the e110 manual that addresses line input connections:
High Level Inputs This feature is included for convenience when needing to connect the E-Sub to a receiver or integrated amplifier that only offers speaker level outputs. It is not the preferred method when a line-level signal is available.
JL Audio believes that when you add a powered subwoofer to a two-way speaker you are now creating a three-way speaker system. When you add a subwoofer to a three-way speaker you are now creating a four-way speaker system.
By using the high-level inputs you are forcing the main speakers to remain full range. Secondly, you are having to run a powered amplifier signal of significant wattage into a set of resistors to reduce the signal level to millivoltage which is acceptable for the input stage of the amplifier on the powered subwoofer.
By keeping the speakers full range you are continuing the midrange distortion on the woofer cone that is simultaneously playing sub bass frequencies while playing up to the internal crossover frequency of the speaker. This is usually:
350 Hz Test Tone on most 3-way speaker models
On your Focal Chora 826 the internal crossover frequency between the woofer and the midrange driver is:
270Hz Test Tone
AND
2200 Hz Test Tone on most 2-way speaker models
Even on the 3-way playing up to the 270Hz point you can hear from the test tone that this is well within the female vocal range. When speakers are playing full range female vocalists are singing from the woofer while it is shaking back and forth as low as you will allow it to go.
So we believe it is not how low your speakers can play down to it is much more important to know high your woofer is playing up to before being crossed over to the next smallest driver (midrange or tweeter).
Additionally, by letting the main speakers play full range you are prevented from allowing the subwoofer to play up to the frequencies that it is designed to play. The reason a HT system processor defaults to 80Hz for the THX crossover point is that typically subwoofers are purpose-designed to play the lowest two octaves (80 to 20 hertz).
If you must play the speakers full range, we advise a
60 Hz for the low pass frequency setting on the subwoofer. Much higher than this and you are "co-playing" a lot of common frequencies between the speaker's woofer and the subwoofer which can lead to smearing and muddiness; especially if the phase alignment is not correct between the subwoofer and the main speaker. Much lower than this and you are restricting the subwoofer from "earning it's keep".
Thank you for providing your complete equipment list. After reading the owners manual of the NAD C388 I see that it is equipped with a set of RCA outputs that are configurable between full range
OR crossed over at 150Hz at 12dB per octave for sending to a powered subwoofer. When configured to the Subwoofer mode it also high passes the the speaker connections going to your Focals at the same frequency and slope (150Hz at 12dB per octave).
This would be our first choice in setup of your system with the e110.
As for placement of a single subwoofer we would recommend the inside edge of one of the two speakers in close proximity and on plane with the front of the speaker cabinet. By placing it there you are able to tune it to the speaker and create what we call a "single entity" between the speaker and the subwoofer. Additionally by being on the inside you are not too far away from the speaker that does not have a subwoofer in its proximity and the subwoofer is "shared" more effectively.
The most important tuning to get correct is the impulse response which the correct positioning of the phase control knob on the e110. When your subwoofer cone and your woofer cone on the Focal are in phase the synchronous motion creates a significant improvement in focus and detail when the two cones stop fighting each other.
That said, there would still be another sound producer in the room that you cannot synchronize to match the motion of the Focal or the e110. This is the out of phase waveform coming out of the port on the Focal 826. If Focal provided port plugs to seal the ports you should use them when adding a powered subwoofer to your system. If not supplied with the Focals, soft foam rubber the type seat cushions are made from can be squeezed and allowed to expand inside the port opening to prevent the smearing that occurs when the port is allowed to contribute to the audio output.
Many of our customers with front firing ports will place the foam into a black sock and tie an knot in it. Then when the squeeze and insert the sock-covered foam it is black and non obtrusive looking.
So here is the recap:
- Seal the ports on the Focals
- Set the NAD RCA outputs to Subwoofer output mode
- Turn the crossover on the e110 to OFF (crossover frequency dial is then bypassed and irrelevant)
- Place the e110 on the inside edge of one of the Focals
- Perform the reverse polarity phase alignment procedure that I am providing as a hyperlink below
- Adjust the gain on the e110 until it is just below the threshold of audibility (not louder than the speaker)
Adjusting Phase Alignment
Enjoy!
Randy
Randy Wagner
Technical Support Specialist
Randy Wagner
Technical Support Specialist