Your response prompted me to contact my bank, and they confirmed that the Tidal payment request didn't meet with the new RBI recurring payment guideline, so they had declined that request outright. It appears that some banks (probably ICICI is one) are still honoring the old payment request, too, but it's just a matter of time before it stops. That said, until Tidal officially starts operating here and follows the new RBI payment guideline, it's a kind of end road...They have.. For spotify I had to set a standing instruction on the card. I subscribed to Tidal after the new rules took effect and I guess thats why its going through.