The one Joan Osborne track I have heard is completely blasphemous. Not even subtle.
Addendum: I saw the above post. Yeah, we're talking about the same song.
I had anticipated some degree of antipathy towards "
One of Us", which is why I had posted a comment beforehand about the song in my review. But I was taken aback when you called this song
"...completely blasphemous. Not even subtle". I read the full lyrics several times but could not find any blatant example of blasphemy.
blasphemy ->
noun 1. a speaking about God or sacred matters in a disrespectful or rude way
2. an action, word or sign that intentionally insults God, or something held sacred, in such a way.
[Chambers 21st Century Dictionary]
There are many examples of blasphemy or insult to religious sentiments in the music world by mainstream or other artistes and bands either overt, covert or in thinly veiled references. Sometimes these people get violently abusive even while performing live on stage. Then there is the controversial incident of Sinead OConnor in SNL which was broadcasting live at that time. I do not condone any of these acts and all deserve to be roundly condemned.
But in this case, I feel certain facts merit attention before we form any opinion of the song in question.
Joan Osborne was born in Kentucky, which is known as the Bluegrass Country. It is the birth-place of this sub-genre of country music. It is also a part of the Gospel Music circuit of the Central and Southern states of U.S.A. Kentucky abuts Tennessee, the capital of Country, Soul, Jazz and Blues music. Nashville is the Capital and the city where the Grand Ole Opry is also located. It is in the heart of the God-fearing and devout Southern States where Gospel music rules the roost. If there had been even a whiff of controversy in Joan Osbornes song, she could not have won a Grammy nomination. Nor would she have been invited to perform in the Grand Ole Opry in 2007. In fact, she would not have survived in the music circles there at all.
Joan Osborne was only the singer of
One of Us. The songwriter was Eric Bazilian. Here is what Eric Bazilian stated in an interview. I quote verbatim from Wiki
The song deals with various aspects of belief in God by asking questions inviting the listener to consider how they might relate to God, such as "Would you call [God's name] to his face?" or "Would you want to see [God's face] if seeing meant that you would have to believe in things like heaven and in Jesus and the saints and all the prophets?" The title of the song comes from religious statement, "What if God was one of us?"
The album version starts off with four lines from a Gospel music song "The Heavenly Airplane": (Italics and stress mine - ML)
Oh, one of these nights at about twelve o'clock
This whole earth is gonna reel and rock
Saints will tremble and cry for pain
For the Lord's gonna come in his heaven airplane.
So you can see that there is no case of blasphemy here at all. The opening lines were quoted from a Gospel Song. The song is a tongue in cheek reference to God from the viewpoint of commoners like us. Havent many of us been confronted by the same dilemma at some point of life or the other?
Its a fun song and should be treated as such. What do you say?
I find Joan Osbornes vocals perfectly suited to the lyrics and love listening to this song just for this!

hyeah: