Illegal(Voot) : As a fan of series' and offbeat cinema, for me, there are few professions that should not be messed with. I mean, when you are using a certain profession, you tend to pick up the tidbits from there for the plot-progression or adding meat to your story. You should not twist it so much that it wrings out the authenticity of the profession just to prove a point, thus diluting it too much. Medicine, Military, Law are few of them. Illegal is one such series. The premise that "In India law allows to sentence a Woman to death, but cannot hang her" is an incorrect and a false statement. There are instances where women in India have been hanged. Now to base a narrative on this, takes the edge off it. Similarly, just to show a strong female lead, the storyline is full of assumptions and "creative liberties". A lawyer, hired to defend someone, openly collaborates with the Prosecutor to punish the accused. The prosecutor openly threatens the accused and records it as an evidence. A reputed firm with a battery of lawyers, "gifts" an amateur 2 sensitive cases which have a potential to bring them down. No one is with the accused during the hearing or trials for a flimsy reason devised at the beginning just to ensure this happens. A lawyer sabotages a defense and goes to join the prosecutor, unpunished. I mean there so many nightmarish liberties taken that at every instance me and my wife were like "Does it even happen that way in the real world?" or " Kuch bhi!" or a more vicious and typical Puneri reaction in assal Marathi!!!!!
Its about a lawyer who has a past (Flimsy as I said and a bit convenient), publicly calls out a famous and most influential Lawyer for molesting her friend even before she gets her feet wet in the domain. Funnily, the friend never asks her to do so. Thus establishing her as a "Truth-loving" lawyer. A bit oxymoron-ish. So, now she is offered a job in Delhi (has connections to her past), where during the hiring interview she shows her "being-truthful-always-no-matter-what" side. She's offered a job in probably the most famous and influential law firm(Owned by her ex and his father!) and is given 2 cases. One pro-bono and other because she is a woman. The case she lands up is about defending a rape accused who is the best friend of her Ex and is immensely rich. The prosecutor is an ex partner of this firm she works in! A novice and an amateur she handles both the cases, cahooting in one with the opposition lawyer and going till the SC for the other. The judges in the SC, especially the CJ is a woman - again convenient. Who smiles and looks as if saying - "I am proud of you my girl", shows agreement with whatever the woman lawyer says!!! Argggh!! Nothing in this series seems real. Its like watching a overhyped and over-exaggerated Salman or Shahrukh movie. Piyush Mishra as JJ and Kubra Sait as Meher are the only ones worth mentioning.
Having watched Boston Legal, Suits, HTGAWM, The Practice, Ek Ruka Hua Faisla, Andha Kanoon, Meri Jung, Damini, To Kill a Mockingbird, A Few Good Men, Michael Clayton etc and read almost every novel by John Grisham, this series seems so pedestrian. Not that the comparison is correct, but then we have Criminal Justice in the same category. Too naïve and too childish, this series no doubt has Vikram Bhatt as creative director and a lopsided, biased writer like Reshu Nath. If there is, I am going to stay away from Season 2.
** Apologies for the rant!!
Its about a lawyer who has a past (Flimsy as I said and a bit convenient), publicly calls out a famous and most influential Lawyer for molesting her friend even before she gets her feet wet in the domain. Funnily, the friend never asks her to do so. Thus establishing her as a "Truth-loving" lawyer. A bit oxymoron-ish. So, now she is offered a job in Delhi (has connections to her past), where during the hiring interview she shows her "being-truthful-always-no-matter-what" side. She's offered a job in probably the most famous and influential law firm(Owned by her ex and his father!) and is given 2 cases. One pro-bono and other because she is a woman. The case she lands up is about defending a rape accused who is the best friend of her Ex and is immensely rich. The prosecutor is an ex partner of this firm she works in! A novice and an amateur she handles both the cases, cahooting in one with the opposition lawyer and going till the SC for the other. The judges in the SC, especially the CJ is a woman - again convenient. Who smiles and looks as if saying - "I am proud of you my girl", shows agreement with whatever the woman lawyer says!!! Argggh!! Nothing in this series seems real. Its like watching a overhyped and over-exaggerated Salman or Shahrukh movie. Piyush Mishra as JJ and Kubra Sait as Meher are the only ones worth mentioning.
Having watched Boston Legal, Suits, HTGAWM, The Practice, Ek Ruka Hua Faisla, Andha Kanoon, Meri Jung, Damini, To Kill a Mockingbird, A Few Good Men, Michael Clayton etc and read almost every novel by John Grisham, this series seems so pedestrian. Not that the comparison is correct, but then we have Criminal Justice in the same category. Too naïve and too childish, this series no doubt has Vikram Bhatt as creative director and a lopsided, biased writer like Reshu Nath. If there is, I am going to stay away from Season 2.
** Apologies for the rant!!
Last edited: