Check out this mind-blowing article about our ISAIGNANI MAESTRO ILAYARAJA AYYA.
Ilayaraja?s music is timeless
Cheers,
Ramesh @ Bangalore
Ramesh,
Link seems to be dead for me.
Check out this mind-blowing article about our ISAIGNANI MAESTRO ILAYARAJA AYYA.
Ilayaraja?s music is timeless
Cheers,
Ramesh @ Bangalore
Murali, pardon me for saying this. I really don't seem to catch anything extraordinary about this video and the song. I watched the video a few times, and even my untrained ears could discern the singers singing out of tune a few times.
Maybe I am missing something.
Cheers
A humble request to fellow forum members: There was a thread "Is A R Rahman That Great" started by one of our friend from this forum and I noticed on certain reply postings few forum members were trying to prove/justify that ARR is the most superior when compared with other music composers. I agree that, every one has the right to express their view but please avoid comparing with others and instead you can share more about the person whom you like to discuss.
For e.g. About an year back there was a thread comparing Mohd. Rafi Ji & Kishore Ji. Personally I felt very bad the way this thread was going on.
For that matter, to the best of my knowledge, ISAIGNANI cannot be compared with anyone. I am sure most of the fellow forum members would not be aware how great ISAIGNANI is.
[1] At his peak time, 6 to 8 recordings used to happen simultaneously on the same day at different recording studios in Chennai. He had 5 to 6 music conductors to assist him. Which composer's recordings has happened to this extent?
[2] At one of the studios, he has spot composed tunes for 6 songs in 30 mts time for a movie. That was his capacity. I am sure that no one has broken this record till date.
I know all these news through my close friends who are professional musicians who play for most of the music composers in south.
Why can't we accept the fact that each and everyone person is unique and they are great in their own way. Please avoid comparisons in future. Thanks.
NOW .....
Check out this mind-blowing article about our ISAIGNANI MAESTRO ILAYARAJA AYYA.
Ilayaraja?s music is timeless
Cheers,
Ramesh @ Bangalore
Re - Ilayaraja and Rahman - I am against comparisons. But no matter how assiduously you avoid it, in your mind you are bound to have a gradation. And that is of course personal.
QUOTE]
Ask a learned musician and he will tell you who has depth in his composition.
Like and dislike is personal. I agree
Re - Ilayaraja and Rahman - I am against comparisons. But no matter how assiduously you avoid it, in your mind you are bound to have a gradation. And that is of course personal.
QUOTE]
Ask a learned musician and he will tell you who has depth in his composition.
Like and dislike is personal. I agree
Square_wave - I have talked to quite a few musicians and in general they do not like Rahman's compositions, while they can, from time to time hum an Ilayaraja tune.
The problem there is with orchestration. The oft repeated reason is that Rahman's instruments take centre stage over the vocals. That is a question of genre, not necessarily musicality.
I dont think there is such a very simple gradation like one of these two has greater 'depth' in their compositions - however you define depth.
Depth is personal as well.
For me, the Dil Gira Dafatan song in Delhi 6 has depth - not in the classical sense but in the context of nuances. Over multiple listening sessions, I have noticed nuances which tell the care with which the song was tuned.
:thumbsup::thumbsup:I find a lot of Ilayaraja fans dismiss Rahman very easily. I am against that. They have different styles. But they are both geniuses. But again this too is personal. Enough said, I guess
Pardon my ignorance as I am new to this. I am having a hard time finding a good quality recording of Raja in Bangalore. Any pointers where I can find such CDs? The ones i heard were too bright on the midrange and highs.