Good to have this thread. Have been looking at 55" LED LCDs since I want to buy one. Here's my mini review of the 2013 models that I have seen so far. I take an mkv of Samsara to play on whichever TV I want to test. So far I've checked it out on around 6 different sets and I have a good idea of the performance of various TVs. So far, I've seen the best performance on the 60" Samsung ES8000 (not a 2013 model). Haven't been able to check this on a Sony HX850 due to the lack of mkv support. I plan to take another reference movie for checking the same on various sets.
Picture settings were set to standard.
Samsung F6800
- Smooth playback (on single core processor Sammys I've seen judder)
- Image was not as bright as required
- Reds were getting blown out
- Noted strobing in a particular high contrast scene
2. Sony W800
- Color reproduction was better than the Sammy
- Too much reflection
- Blacks could be better, noted a tinge
- Detail was getting smeared
Compared the W800 to an HX850 using the Sony demo BD and played the Avengers clip.
The HX850 won this comparison hands down. The W800 made the video look like a soap opera - the frame rate was just not right. The clip definitely didn't have the 'cine' look on both the W800 and the HX850 but it looked much better on the older Sony.
There's no way I could even consider the W800. Will wait for the W900 or just see if I get the HX850 for a good price.