Is Subwoofer must along with 3-way towers???

hi docguha, the ear is the best judge so get your floor standers up first and then decide whether you need to add on a sub. Although many may disagree, from personal experience, i can vouch that your floorstander's woofer cone size would ultimately force your decision in favour or against adding on a sub (assuming your amp can drive the floorstanders suitably). Most of the modern floor standers with 6inch woofers (or smaller) have been designed for use with a sub. I have compared my vintage BPL Sanyo 700T 4-Way floorstanders (has 2 8inch woofers, 1 active and 1 passive) to some of the modern floorstanders from Jamo and JBL and my vintage towers were miles ahead in bass reproduction. I have had the opportunity to connect my very same NAD 216thx poweramp to a pair of vintage Sony floorstanders with 12 inch woofers and the bass kicked in even deeper. The floorstanders of old definitelyl produce more deep bass when compared to the modern ones with small cone surfaces. I suggest you look at towers with 8 inch woofers or 10 inch side-firing woofers...again, many pundits may disagree with my statement and findings, however you need to listen for yourself to judge. Btw, I listen to heavy metal music mostly where bass reproduction is paramount. My room size is 12ft by 16ft. Kindly check my signature for more details on my equipment. Thanks
 
well thanx for all the valuable suggestion,i tried to search all the threads in the speaker section,but there was no info regarding my query,still my query is half answered.i guess there is a logic/principle behind every setup,forget bout room dimension,furniture,living room,type of music, budgetary etc.which no one explained.i wanted a simple explanation.but the esteemed members went too far.well i dont want to be spoon fed or develop six packs in a baby.still hoping to get my doubts clear.regards

I understand first you want to know a 2-way, 3-way speaker. I am no expert here but here's some explanation.

2 Way, 2.5 Way, 3 Way refers to a design of a speaker. Generally how frequencies are crossed in a speaker.

1. 2 Way speaker:
These can be BS or FS which will typically has two drivers viz. a Tweeter and a Woofer Driver. Passive crossovers in the speaker distributes the frequencies to these drivers. Typically 2.5khz and above are send to tweeters and <2.5khz to woofer. (Different manufacturer will adopt different frequencies. Some will take 2.6khz, some @ 2.4khz, etc.)

2. 2.5 Way speaker:
These are generally FS which will typically has three drivers viz. a Tweeter and 2 Woofers. Passive crossovers in the speaker distributes the frequencies to these drivers. Typically 2.5khz and above are send to tweeters, 1khz to 2.5khz to woofer and below 1khz to woofer 2. (Different manufacturer will adopt different frequencies) These are called 2.5 way since woofer 2 is not dedicated to bass frequencies which is generally < 500-600hz.

3. 3 Way speaker:
These are generally FS which will typically has three or four drivers viz. a Tweeter and a mid range and 2 Woofers. Passive crossovers in the speaker distributes the frequencies to these drivers. Typically 2.5khz and above are send to tweeters, 600 hz to 2.5khz to mid range and woofer 1 and below 600khz to woofer 2. (Different manufacturer will adopt different frequencies)

3 way gives you more dynamics in mid range and low bass reproduction as drivers are dedicated for mid and low frequencies. However, some people experience that in mid sized / small rooms, a 3 way with 4 drivers sound more boomy (Does not apply in all cases) and hence suggest a 2.5 way speaker for these areas / 2 way + a subwoofer.

Your another question is sub reqd. with 3 way towers.
My answer is no if you have a quality built speakers. I have 2.5way speakers in my 210sft living room and it outperforms my sub.

Some of the forum members suggested that you can add sub later if you feel the need. But in your case, i think you need to first decide whether you need a sub later or not.

Your requirement is purely a stereo setup. Most of the Int Amps do not have a Pre Out for Sub so adding a sub later becomes difficult. If you buy an AVR for Stereo Setup, i think you will be compromising. However, there are some Stereo Receivers available with Pre Out for Sub but haven't seen them personally in any of the AV shops (Not saying its difficult). Probably one has to buy without auditioning.
 
i started with a similar problem.
I listened to bookshelf(jbl control one's) speakers and knew that i would need a sub with those bookshelf's so i listened to towers (ms carnival 6) and was happy with the low end on those speakers.
So i bought a sherwood avr and yamaha ns 8390 towers (used) as i am not very particular on music and i mostly watch movies next i will be adding centre and surround from yamaha.
So u should go out and listen to various setups and u will be able to judge exactly what u need.
My two paisa worth :)
 
@drkaushik,@reubensm,@dj_79 and @arunhc
thanx for the detailed n logical explainataion.that was the point i was trying to make.the fact is that whenever i visited a showroom/audition room,i some what felt the sound is tweaked.only sonodyne was producing the true sound from the 3-way sonus tower(with n without a separate sub).rest were some 10 towers/5 bs/5 subs.lots of cable.cant find which speaker is producing what sound,even the sales guy is also confused(except profx).
3 way gives you more dynamics in mid range and low bass reproduction as drivers are dedicated for mid and low frequencies. However, some people experience that in mid sized / small rooms, a 3 way with 4 drivers sound more boomy (Does not apply in all cases) and hence suggest a 2.5 way speaker for these areas / 2 way + a subwoofer.
this is the exact explaination
thanx to all
regards
 
@drkaushik,@reubensm,@dj_79 and @arunhc
thanx for the detailed n logical explainataion.that was the point i was trying to make.the fact is that whenever i visited a showroom/audition room,i some what felt the sound is tweaked.only sonodyne was producing the true sound from the 3-way sonus tower(with n without a separate sub).rest were some 10 towers/5 bs/5 subs.lots of cable.cant find which speaker is producing what sound,even the sales guy is also confused(except profx).

this is the exact explaination
thanx to all
regards

hey docguha
did you finalised your setup? keep us posted.
 
Join WhatsApp Channel to get HiFiMART.com Offers & Deals delivered to your smartphone!
Back
Top