just4kix
Well-Known Member
Not trying to dissuade you or anyone from buying. This is how I rate HP movies:
Warning: Mild spoilers
I have movies 1~5 on DVD and 6~8 on BD. I did not think that buying BD copies of movies 1~5 was worth (except may be HP-1).
Warning: Mild spoilers
- The Philosopher's (Sorcerer's) Stone: 4.5/5
Very faithful to the book. Very good narration, editing, etc. Captivating to the end.
. - The Chamber of Secrets: 4/5
Once again fairly faithful to the book. Good direction. I would rate Chris Columbus to be the best director of the lot considering that he had rank amateur children to direct.
. - The Prisoner of Azkaban: 2/5
A classic case of how one of the best books/story of the franchise is murdered in film. Tried to introduce wacky comedy, smart-ass talking shrunken heads! Really? Sirius Black played by Gary Oldman was the saviour to an extent.
. - The Goblet of Fire: 3.5/5
Very fast paced and exciting. Bit spoiled because the First Task of the tri-wizard tournament was way overplayed and overshadowing. Comparatively, the third and most difficult task was pale and uninteresting. Changed the ending that irked me. But good movie overall.
. - The Order of the Phoenix: 3/5
Now this was a real challenge. How does one fit a 880+ pages book into 2+ hours movie? I would have loved to have it split into part-I and part-II to do some justice. Leaves out (or barely touches) some important details - The legacy of HP and LV and why HP is the chosen one. Average, overall.
. - The Half Blood Prince: 3.5/5
Same problem of the previous movie - how to crunch the details into 2+ hours? Chopped out quite a few LV memories. Ginny/Harry romance downplayed (OK, no issues). Snape did not get the screen presence that he deserved. Good, overall.
. - The Deathly Hallows - Part I: 5/5
Now this was really how the movies should have been made. People who watched the movies only without reading the books found it boring, sans action, etc. But it does build the tension very well. I loved every bit of it. You decide.
. - The Deathly Hallows - Part II: 4/5
A little disappointed after the high of the previous movie. Ending was changed which again irked me no end. HP vs. LV: the fight was way different in the book. I guess, director's perogative. Can wands be broken by ordinary force? I doubt. But the much missing action of the previous movie was present now.
I have movies 1~5 on DVD and 6~8 on BD. I did not think that buying BD copies of movies 1~5 was worth (except may be HP-1).
Last edited: