Fascinating stuff, Rosh. Do you guys have a website? Maybe I'd better ask google in case answering that might be advertising! I don't play music, just enjoy it. Similarly, with IndiaMike, I'm glad to say that I've just been an ordinary member for some years now. Forum moderating is hard work!
A Little More on Genelec
Having read with great interest about the Genelec event in Mumbai, I was delighted that they were able to make it, albeit for a shortened demonstration of just one pair of speakers from their range. Hopefuly they will be able to come again one day for a longer session.
Genelec speakers aim for flat, unflavoured sound. As such, they are probably not the choice of many a hifi listener. In the catalogue, there is one photograph of their littlest model flanking a MacBook, all the others are of pro-audio studios, and not a single living room. Howoever, it seems that some people
are taking this sound into their homes On display was one of their digital-input DSP series. I think it was the
8240A. Between the laptop and the speakers was the
Motu Microbook interface. It could be any similar of course: Clifford recommended not to use a mother-boad built-in.
Active: No amplifier required. Digital: No DAC required. DSP: things get a little more complex!
Active speakers is a well understood concept and needs no further comment, except to note that these 2-way speakers do not have just one amplifier feeding a crossover. they have an amplifier for each driver! Thus, the woofer amp is precisely tailored to feed the woofer driver and the tweeter amplifier is precisely tailored to feed the tweeter. Some stuff about impedence I did not understand; next time maybe, or someone else could fill in the gap?
Digital Input is not unknown, either. At the lower end of the market, my response is, these speakers cost Rs.
x, and that has to be split over amplifier, drivers, case
and DAC? That's spreading it a bit thin, and maybe we can't expect that much of each component. The DAC may be no better than the ones that PC motherboards comes with.
However, Genelec are not at the lower end of the market, by any means. In size, these were "bookshelf;" in price, they were around Rs.3.5 Lakh. They are engineered to sound superb, if anyone wants to feed the analogue input from an another DAC, they can, but it would be a waste.
It is even possible for the speakers to process digital 5.1 sound, in which case the original signal is fed to the subwoofer.
DSP (Digital Sound Processing). The speakers have, as mentioned, a digital input. This signal (whether from pro sound gear or even just the RCA output of a CD deck) gets split into two channels at the first speaker, the second channel being passed to the second speaker. There is also another set of connections, via cat-5 cable, from a Genelec box about the size of a laptop power supply. This is connected to laptop/PC. There is a microphone which is placed in the listening position. Controlled by the Genelec software, each speaker outputs a sweep tone. The tone "as heard" by the mic is used to calculate the DSP settings, which are then fed back to speakers to provide correct tonal and timing settings for that listening position.
This information can be saved on the speakers, in which case, the control equipment and cables can now be put away. Alternatively, different listening-position profiles can be saved on the PC and uploaded to the speakers when needed. They can also be manually tweaked.
If the PC remains connected, it can also be used to control the volume of the speakers. This is a digitally controlled
analogue volume control: the bit depth/resolution is not affected as the volume is reduced.
The physical appearance is pro-studio. Not hard, because just about surface is curved, but not the perfect "piece of furniture" for the traditional living room. However, if the customer is prepared to wait, they can have any colour they want! Apparently, even veneered finish can be made.
A very interesting demo --- that did nothing to reduce my potentially-expensive interest in studio monitoring speakers