sam9s
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2009
- Messages
- 5,239
- Points
- 113
Sam9s - Even though your advice is quite accurate, I guess the fact remains that there are quite a few users (including me) who would end up using the same speakers for both movies/music because of various constraints. The usage would be in different ratios, but unfortunately (at least in my case), I do not have the luxury of ideally having two different set ups for music and movies, so I would also end up auditioning both movies/music, if I upgrade in the future.
Can someone explain how some speakers are better for music and some for movies? I can imagine that the more musical speakers may have a bit of mellowness to them but the ones for the movies are very transparent and neutral. I am really curious about this.
well lets put it this way, speakers might not be the exact precise reason for sounding different in movies/music, it might be the way the staging/Quality/precision of the sound we hear making the difference. But usually and generally, for movies one does not look for tonal accuracy, or precise mids and vocals. Most of us would look for cinematic staging, heaviness, bass, surround effects and clarity of the centre with dialogues.
Which is (again mostly as I said) completely opposite to when we listen to music, where music vocals, stereo separation, tonal difference (how warm or how bright) matters a lot.
It was again said that speakers which can bring out every note of the recording accurately will anyhow work good in movies, as they can cover a wide spectrum of sound, but my very personal experience in so many auditions I have taken, speaks differently. This might be again coz of the fact, how we (or I for that matter) perceive sound in different scenarios, as speakers high in music quality, for me, did not sound at all good in Movies, perfect example QUAD. (EPOS were still better) .....Baring few exceptions like Paradigm that for me were closest when it came to bridging quality in both Movies and Music. (Again absolutely neglecting elite brands like Martin Logan, Magnepan etc.)
Last edited: